The OP has been updated with:
-results from our last tournament
(this included Sully, Davy Jones, Syndrome, Tonto, Mrs. Incredible, Barbossa, Sparrow, Jack Skellington, Mr. Incredible, Woody and The Lone Ranger)
-match up data from the last tournament (including character analysis' for new characters
-a new list that includes Skellington, Ranger and Tonto
Additionally, we recently obtained Anna and Elsa and have briefly tested them. From our initial results, we put Anna lower on the list towards Rapunzel (tier3) and Elsa higher on the list towards Mickey and Mike (but not in tier1). I believe that further testing will put Elsa as the 5th character in tier1 (: